November is zombie month – the perfect time to talk about undead infrastructure that has become impossible to maintain, or whose future usefulness is increasingly uncertain. Gas networks are a case in point (spoiler alert: our latest study on this topic will be published very soon!).
At a recent conference, Kurt Vandenberghe, Director-General of DG CLIMA at the European Commission, challenged participants to have the courage to put necessary “creative destruction” on the agenda. Is this a new concept in European political vocabulary? In his opinion, Europe’s slow pace of transition is not the result of a lack of ambition. We are on track, but we need to remove the obstacles standing in the way of investment.
Kurt Vandenberghe has identified three such obstacles.
First and foremost, an aversion to innovation. This prevents us from embracing “creative destruction”. The automotive industry is perhaps the most obvious example of a zombie sector. Prolonging the life of combustion-engine technology will not take us forward. On the contrary, it significantly delays the industry’s necessary shift towards electric vehicles, turning it into a zombie industry. “Creative destruction”, by contrast, enables us to plan technological change through innovation policies.
I must admit, however, that I struggle to see how this fits with the Commission’s decision not to renew the Just Transition Fund, whose very purpose was to support this kind of transformation.
The second obstacle is the lack of predictability of the legislative framework. Senior European officials keep repeating the same old thing: “The future (of the EU ETS) is not about changing the destination. It is about ensuring the most efficient journey” (Rosalinde van der Vlies, Director DG CLIMA).
Yet, without a clear timetable for transposing directives – whether the Energy Efficiency Directive or ETS2 – stakeholders across the relevant sectors are unable to position themselves. France provides a particularly telling example: a rather uncreative dismantling of policies that have successfully supported decarbonisation and remain essential to local authorities. Gone is the “Fonds Chaleur”, which supports the development of district heating and cooling networks. Goodbye to renovation grant schemes and to programmes tackling energy poverty! The aim is supposedly to redirect funding towards the electrification of end-use applications, as if there were no need to reduce demand and dependence…
This announcement, alongside several others over recent months, does little to provide businesses with the predictability they need. It also signals a continuing erosion of state support for local project development capacity. This has nothing to do with “creative destruction”. We are simply destroying tools, agencies and programmes that take years to set up and roll out and give all local areas access to support. I hope some local authorities will find the strength to preserve this expertise, bring it in-house, share it and safeguard all that public investment in institutions and people.
Predictability also requires a common framework. This is precisely the ambition of the new European framework for resilience, which proposes using a common reference scenario to anticipate climate risks across Europe. Requiring governments to develop national strategies that clarify the distribution of risks and responsibilities is certainly a good starting point. But, as mentioned above, if the trend is to leave local authorities without the means to take action, this may not be enough. Some institutional structures may well be zombies, but those providing local project development support are the missing link for large-scale investment in the transition and the implementation of European directives!
The final obstacle to speeding up the transition is said to be a lack of European integration. There is some irony in hearing this from the Commission, given that its proposal for the 2028–2034 budget amounts to the renationalisation of spending, without defining real priorities. The idea seems to be to give Member States considerable flexibility to allocate resources according to their needs.
The European dimension cannot simply mean giving the Commission greater powers to decide on its own, as in its proposals on energy networks, under which Brussels would determine the methodology for setting network charges. Or only releasing EU funding when Member States agree to reforms.
Yes, there is indeed a lack of Europe, but what we need is a Europe that relies on those who actually deliver: local authorities and businesses. Not a Europe that confines debate to Member States and the Commission, leaving parliaments and citizens on the sidelines. They are best placed to discuss real infrastructure needs, how to share the costs of infrastructure that will not be needed in the future, how to allocate access to energy, and how to finance the transition equitably.
Let’s hope that the forthcoming European regulation on the governance of energy and climate policies will significantly strengthen coordination between all levels of decision-making, ensuring that those responsible for implementation are genuinely involved and preventing multi-level governance from becoming yet another zombie…